For the last few months, Civil Beat editors have been getting an increasing barrage of AI-generated emails, from an off-shore builder eager to be a future source (clearly autogenerated by a story about a kauhale) to a marketing firm that wants to automatically post stories on our site and a “news” site that wants to repost all of ours — for free!

But the one that caught our eye the most had this subject line: “Honolulu could have a daily paper.”

Putting aside the fact that Honolulu already has a daily paper — albeit one with fewer and fewer pages each year — we were intrigued by what the email was pitching: a national effort to bring a “daily local paper back to towns that lost theirs.”

How might one do this? By becoming the editor-in-chief or publisher of an AI-powered local news site for the starting price of $299. No journalism experience required. (We emailed the company behind the pitch hoping to learn more about how AI “News Agents” could help bolster the dwindling power of the Fourth Estate but have not heard back.)

While the Star-Advertiser is thankfully still plugging along, the truth is that Hawaiʻi has become one of the nation’s many news deserts. 

It’s a fact made all the more heartbreaking by Hawaiʻi’s storied media legacy. 

The Hawaiian Kingdom had one of the highest literacy rates in the world, and — despite Hawaiʻi’s geographic isolation — in the mid-1800s, people here were more versed in global affairs than residents in many parts of the United States. Hundreds of ships a year docked at harbors in Honolulu and Lahaina, and local publishers were eager to get their hands on whatever news those ships carried with them. 

“Little rowboats would go out and pick up the newspapers they had collected from around the world,” local historian Anita Manning told Civil Beat in 2019. It was “like the Twitter of its day.”

U.S. President Abraham Lincoln’s assassination was front-page news when it reached Hawaii on 11 May 1865. (Papakilo Hawaiian Newspaper Database)

The appetite for news was seemingly insatiable. 

Between the mid-19th century and the start of the millennium, more than 1,200 different newspapers were printed in the islands. More than 100 were in ʻŌlelo Hawaiʻi, and the collection of surviving Hawaiian language newspapers is “one of the largest repositories of Indigenous language material” in the world. 

Some of the reporters and editors in our newsroom entered this field long after the precipitous decline of newspapers that came with the internet age. Others remember an era when newsrooms were in heavy competition with each other, even smaller regional newspapers had the budget to send reporters far afield to chase a scoop. Fifty years ago this week, back when Hawaiʻi had two major daily newspapers, the Sunday edition for just one of them clocked in at 266 pages. 

When Civil Beat transitioned to a nonprofit a decade ago, sites like ours were seen as a bright spot in an otherwise dreary landscape. In 2015, there were roughly 200 nonprofit newsrooms in the U.S. Last year there were more than 400 digital-first nonprofit newsrooms. 

But even nonprofit news sites are facing another major media transformation, one that could be as disruptive as the entry of the World Wide Web: the age of AI. 

Rose and James used to read the headlines on The Garden Island’s website. Alas, the program has been cancelled. (Screenshot/2024)

Some of the early forays of AI into journalism were humorous (anyone remember when The Garden Island debuted two AI avatars reading the news.) But AI is becoming increasingly hard to spot, and at the same time, its incursions are becoming too pervasive to ignore. It’s by no means a scientific study, but this bit of research from a San Francisco marketing company merits real concern and further investigation: “AI Now Writes as Many Online Articles as Humans.”

A company called Hoodline that operates a Honolulu news site publishes several stories a day about Hawaiʻi. One from a few days ago about health insurance hikes by HMSA and other local insurers says it was written by Marc Suzuki. There is, however, no Marc Suzuki. 

Hoodline’s story has a little “ai” symbol next to Suzuki’s byline, but it takes some real research to figure out that button means Suzuki is a fictitious persona, with a Japanese surname chosen perhaps make him seem local and create trust with the local community. (Hoodline’s CEO has said that names are chosen at random by AI and not meant to ethnically mirror local communities, but in 2024 Nieman Lab found a notable trend in how the names shifted based on local demographics.) 

AI is changing how news is produced and it’s also changing how people find news. Algorithms on social, search settings, chatbots. It’s hard to tell how and where people will be getting their news in the decades to come. 

So where does that leave us? In the same place journalists have been for the last several decades: Needing to adapt and be nimble. 

Civil Beat launched a new website last week — not because of AI specifically, though we hope that our transition will protect our site from crippling bot attacks, which, surprise!, tend to originate from cities with large data centers, which are being rapidly built to accommodate the voracious needs of AI. Our new site still has some kinks, but it will also give us new tools to help us be flexible in the next few years. We’ll be able to get information up faster, embed videos directly on our homepage, add bite-sized takeaways to stories, and more easily include content from Civil Beat archives that are relevant to issues today. 

And though we are cautious about AI, we’re leaning on it for what we think is its current best use here: sorting through thousands of hours of government meetings to make sure that anyone can hone in on exactly what our elected officials are doing during the legislative session in every hearing — and share links to the exact moment they said something so that you can get directly to the source of information, too. (You can read more about Digital Democracy and find our full AI policy here.) 

And rather than generating avatars with ethnic-sounding names tailored to Hawaiʻi, we’re continuing to invest in our pipeline program to nurture the next generation of local journalists: people from here who will be deeply committed to being the watchdogs for their community and reporting stories that can often only be told by creating deep human connections. 

These future reporters, like the ones currently in our newsroom, will have to enjoy a challenge. It’s sort of essential in our line of business.

The future of news is a little scary. But it’s definitely not boring. 

— Jessica Terrell, Civil Beat Managing Editor

Go deeper: 

Hawaiʻi Supreme Court Says Current Rules Are Enough To Prevent AI Abuses
Despite lawyers citing fake, AI-generated citations in court documents, a new report finds existing rules provide adequate safeguards.

Artificial Intelligence Is Here To Stay. Are Hawaiʻi Schools Ready?
From preschoolers to high school seniors, Hawaiʻi students share how artificial intelligence is shaping their learning and plans for the future.

Schatz Pushes AI Oversight As Tech Goes Rogue: ‘Humans In Control’
In an interview with Civil Beat, Hawaiʻi’s senior senator explains why Congress needs to set up AI safety rules now before something “horrifying” happens.

How We’re Thinking About AI At Civil Beat
From typewriters onward, newsrooms have benefited from technological advances. Artificial intelligence, however, offers particular challenges.

Spotting AI: ‘It’s The Hair’ 

Courtney Teague, our director of audience at Civil Beat, became known this election season as something of a whiz when it came to identifying AI-generated photos. When her eagle eyes spotted something amiss, there would occasionally be a groan in the newsroom (no one wants to hear at the end of the day that the only photo we have for a political candidate might need to be pulled from publication) but we came to rely on her as AI-generated photos became a more common occurrence. 

Courtney Teague, our directory of audience, is a whiz at picking hair products — and spotting fake photos based on hairstyles. (Kawika Lopez)

Courtney, a UH grad who first joined Civil Beat as an intern in 2016, worked at several news operations in California before returning to us to head newsletters and then our overall audience strategy. She says the 2026 campaign cycle was the first where she recalls spotting so many — at least a dozen by her estimation — AI-generated photos from political candidates. She found it particularly disheartening to see seasoned politicians shopping around fake images of themselves. 

So what’s her secret for ferreting out the fakery? It’s all about the hair. 

“It just looks like a cartoon,” Courtney says. Basically, it’s too perfect. 

Courtney’s got a bit of an obsession with hairstyles — and a full Pinterest board to prove it — and she usually has the best-coiffed hair in the office. But even with her vast knowledge and strong opinions on hair products, she’s got a few stray wisps and some frizz on even the best day. Not so on many of the AI photos she’s been spotting. “It all just looks like one piece if you zoom in on it,” she says. 

The problem is AI is getting better at making things like hair seem a little more realistic, adding in some imperfections as needed. So what’s the takeaway? 

“I hope that this isn’t too cynical, but I would just say assume it’s fake unless you know where it’s coming from,” Courtney says. “I myself am stumped by stuff in my own feed all the time, and I feel like I have a pretty good eye for it.”

Can you spot what’s real? 

The decline in the number of journalists nationally over the last few decades has been paired with a remarkable growth in the number of public relations professionals. We don’t dislike PR folks — reporters rely on them daily for critical information and many government spokespeople were once our colleagues. But it’s alarming that even as there are fewer watchdogs tracking what local officials are doing, there are more people tasked with promoting them. 

The amount of money the state spent publicizing the work of the no-bid contractor building homeless villages in Hawaiʻi actually raised some serious eyebrows in a recent Legislative hearing. 

“Oh god, the public relations,” State Sen. Joy San Buenaventura said. “I mean why do we even need to publicize a homeless initiative?”

Lawmakers were also concerned about other more questionable expenses that HomeAid was reimbursed for by the state, costs that had little to do with housing the homeless. Take our quiz to see if you can spot which expenses the state reimbursed HomeAid for.