The Maui Police Commission declined on Wednesday to reinstate Maui Police Chief John Pelletier, who was placed on paid administrative leave last month pending an investigation into his oversight of a department unit whose leader was arrested by federal authorities.
Honolulu attorney Eric Seitz, representing Pelletier, demanded that the chief be allowed to continue working while the investigation is carried out, arguing that placing the chief on leave harmed his reputation and amounted to disciplinary action.
“Then I won’t have to sue you,” he told the commissioners after waiting about six hours to testify.

Toni Rojas and other volunteer members of the commission said the action was intended to ensure the integrity and independence of the investigation.
“It supports public trust and accountability, and it preserves due process and fairness,” Rojas told Seitz before the commission voted 6-1 to keep Pelletier on leave until the investigation is concluded. “I saw this as a temporary measure. We’re helping protect the chief’s employment rights, his livelihood, while the facts are all being reviewed.”
Commissioners also voted to instruct an outside investigator to expand the scope of an existing inquiry — related to a high-profile property damage case — to include the chief’s role in the department’s response. Additionally, they agreed to open another investigation into Pelletier’s comments and conduct since being placed on leave.
The commissioners took the action after hearing hours of testimony from about 30 people, many of whom expressed support for Pelletier and said they believed he was committed to rooting out corruption within the department. Others voiced serious concerns about his leadership style and said the chief appeared to be overly defensive and reluctant to accept accountability.
“We’re helping protect the chief’s employment rights, his livelihood, while the facts are all being reviewed.”
Toni Rojas, member of the Maui Police Commission
In October, the commission unanimously voted to place Pelletier on paid administrative leave while it investigates his supervision of the Criminal Intelligence Unit. The now-dissolved unit reported directly to the chief and was led by Lt. Michael Vaituulala, who is facing federal charges after prosecutors said he had been accepting bribes and using his police powers to protect cockfight organizers, drug traffickers and illegal fireworks distributors.
Two days later, Pelletier alleged during a press conference that Mayor Richard Bissen has for months been the subject of separate criminal investigations by the Hawaiʻi Attorney General’s Office and the Maui Police Department. The chief said he believed that Bissen retaliated by influencing the commission’s decision to place him on leave, a claim that the mayor denied.
Maui County Prosecutor Andrew Martin has since said that Bissen is not the subject of a state criminal investigation into allegations of fraud and financial mismanagement.
After the meeting, Seitz told reporters that he had already drafted a lawsuit and was expecting to file it in the next week.
“They can’t just simply remove him as they’ve done on some ambiguous charges,” he said. They’ve got to state those charges.nThey’ve got to give him an opportunity to respond. They’ve got to conduct a hearing.”
Commission Chair Frank Tam reiterated that commissioners were not accusing Pelletier of wrongdoing.

“All we’re saying is that it would be in the best interest of the investigation for him not to remain in place.”
Based on guidance from corporation counsel, Tam said he was confident that the commission had not acted innappropriately.
