Reworld officials have asserted that a flat groundwater table along Oʻahu’s ʻEwa plain is helping keep the massive fuel spill at H-Power contained to the area right around the city incinerator plant. 

There’s no indication the contamination has reached the nearby shoreline, they said Thursday, and they expressed little concern that it would.

However, local hydrologists and community members say the situation there is far more complex and strong concerns remain that the fuel could eventually seep into West Oʻahu’s fragile coastal ecosystem.

Campbell Industrial Park aerial.
Experts say there are strong concerns that the H-Power fuel spill at Campbell Industrial Park could reach the nearby shoreline. (Cory Lum/Civil Beat/2017)

The water table there may be flat, University of Hawaiʻi Mānoa hydrologist Chris Shuler said, but the area’s underground caves, cracks and fissures might also give the polluted water faster pathways to the ocean.

Those formations are part of the mostly limestone subterranean landscape that connects that corner of West Oʻahu to the shoreline, said Shuler, who’s studied the hydrology there in recent years. 

“There’s a high potential for any fluid —  water or petroleum — to move through that kind of an aquifer quickly,” Shuler said Friday. The fuel-polluted water could move in ways that “are hard to understand,” Shuler said, without knowing all the potential underground pathways.

The Environmental Protection Agency, meanwhile, confirmed Friday that it has opened an investigation into the spill based on its proximity to the shoreline. An agency spokesman said it’s been helping the state Health Department since Aug. 21, when state officials first reached out to the federal agency.

Shuler’s comments came after Reworld Vice President Michael Van Brunt on Thursday compared the leak of an estimated 400,000 gallons of incinerator fuel from an underground pipe at H-Power earlier this year to spilling water on a flat table. 

“It will spread out, but it’ll stop,” Van Brunt said during a press conference held in Honolulu Mayor Rick Blangiardi’s office. “It helps us keep it in that generalized area. We know where the material is. It’s sitting mostly below the site.”

Brunt displayed a map with the 22 monitoring wells Reworld has installed since its workers reported the spill in May. Several wells to the west of the H-Power facility have not detected the fuel, according to the Reworld map. The company, which contracts with the city to run H-Power, is still working to install monitoring wells south of the incinerator plant.

“It has stayed on site, it has not migrated to the coast,” Brunt said.

Shuler said the map offers an incomplete, two-dimensional picture. 

It’s possible, he said, for the fuel to move past the area and toward the shoreline at depths not monitored by the wells. Reworld, Shuler said, should release more data from the wells, including the depths at which they’re monitoring.

“When not a lot of information is shared, that doesn’t help with trust-building,” Shuler said. “I’d be happy to see all the information that’s available.” 

Groundwater discharges into coastal waters near the plant at various spots, he added.

‘More Than Just An Environmental Thing’

Board of Water Supply Manager and Chief Engineer Ernie Lau told Civil Beat Friday that the area’s 400-foot-thick “caprock” layer, made of limestone and muddy clay, will prompt the fuel to flow horizontally toward the coast, not vertically down into the ground.

That means there’s no risk to the island’s drinking water supply, but the coast is a different concern.

Community advocates and volunteers, meanwhile, fear the spill could jeopardize efforts to restore native, endangered ‘Ewa Hinahina plants at the Kīpuka o Kāhinahina plant sanctuary just west of the H-Power facility.

A map showing boundaries of the H-Power fuel spill
This map, first displayed by Reworld executives, shows how far the company believes the fuel spill has spread based on its monitoring wells. The dotted line, which includes part of the Kīpuka o Kāhinahina sanctuary, shows Reworld’s believed boundary. The black dots represent monitoring wells where the fuel has not been detected. (Courtesy: City and County of Honolulu)

The plant once grew abundantly across the ʻEwa plain, said Ulukoa Duhaylonsod, cultural director and founder of the nonprofit Kauiki o Kapo. Decades of industrialization decimated the plant, prompting federal officials to place it on the endangered species list.

The Kipuka sanctuary is one of the last places to find ‘ewa hinahina on Oʻahu, Duhaylonsod said. His nonprofit has struggled to keep the plant alive on city-owned sanctuary land set between H-Power and an industrial yard.

Van Brunt’s map indicates the spill has already reached the sanctuary.

The plants at the sanctuary rely on the brackish groundwater there to survive, said Duhaylonsod, who’s from the area. The area’s aquifer used to have a top freshwater layer, he added, before heavy industrialization depleted it.

“This is more than just an environmental thing. This is our home,” Duhaylonsod said. “This is the place that we grew up, that we all love. So we malama because we care, because we love this place.”

He added that community-led plans are underway to test the groundwater at the sanctuary.

Civil Beat Reporters Matthew Leonard and Ben Angarone contributed.