Can the state’s homeless policy be saved from the awesome clutches of The Indignation Machine?
All that indignation has come about from state auditor Les Kondo’s critical assessment of Gov. Josh Green’s flagship kauhale tiny house homeless program.
It’s turned into a morality play, good melodrama but awful governance. It is diverting us from the main question: Do kauhale do the job?
No one really has an answer to this, except for the governor. He thinks the kauhale program is working great and is so confident that he dismisses anyone, such as the auditor, who has the gall to point out problems.
There is plenty to be indignant about. Green’s angry self-martyrdom aside – he’s accused State Auditor Less Kondo of carrying out a “personal vendetta” against him – the final auditor’s report is even more damning than its preliminary one.
Kondo’s task was limited and defined by the rules of his job: Find out whether kauhale money has been spent appropriately — what Kondo did.
By auditor standards, the defenses of the governor’s homeless team are pitifully weak.
Green’s mandate is different from the auditor’s. The difference is at the heart of the anger.
It’s time for some serious anger management in order to confront the homeless issue head-on.
Three steps:
Take a breath. Take another look. Take a closer look.
Take A Breath
Green needs to get out of his defensive posture. He just won reelection by a bigger margin than any other governor in Hawai‘i’s history. So he has a cushion, giving him a chance to reflect on just how counterproductive his stance on kauhale has become.
Most of all, he needs to accept the fact that Kondo is not simply a roadblock but someone who has a legitimate, helpful role.

As for Kondo taking a breath: he’s done his job and done it well. His work is done here. The problem is about the homeless, not about him.
Legislators also need to take a breath and remind themselves about the limits of legislative indignation.
The recent hearings show that the legislators were really good at finding fault with kauhale’s slipshod ways. Fine, as far as it goes.
But there’s a big difference between anger and successful legislative oversight.
Anger and threats alone change nothing, easier to fulminate than fulfil. The best recent example of this is the dunderheaded administration of the Convention Center repairs. Legislators have been criticizing the center’s construction and destruction from its very beginning, yet the mess is getting bigger.
Take Another Look: Emergency Proclamations
The basis for the governor’s actions is an emergency proclamation. Hawai‘i law is typical in that it allows the governor or mayor to determine when an emergency exists.
The governor used an emergency proclamation to create the kauhale program.
The legislators’ main control is their ongoing kauhale investigation.
Let’s face it. The homeless issue is so awful and complicated, that emergency powers are the only way to go.

Ideas showcases stories, opinion and analysis about Hawaiʻi, from the state’s sharpest thinkers, to stretch our collective thinking about a problem or an issue. Email news@civilbeat.org to submit an idea or an essay.
Keep in mind how often you complain about how badly things get done in Hawai‘i – you know, delays, broken deadlines, stuff that drives you nuts, and how upset you become when you see a homeless person in your neighborhood.
But emergency power is not absolute power. It is not more important than the auditor’s power. The two powers run alongside one another.
“Get it done!” and “Do it right!” are a complicated mixture requiring more than dueling kuleana.
Take A Closer Look
We know almost nothing about kauhale’s effectiveness. Green confidently claims it has reduced the percentage living on the streets by 13%.
That’s an assertion based on flawed assumptions. The last homeless count did show a 13% reduction, but there’s no evidence that kauhale was the key reason. And there is so much more to know.
There’s been nothing close to a careful evaluation of kauhale’s impact. A Portland State University study of a similar situation in Portland would be a good model to follow.
It was done not by advocates but by a group specializing in homeless research.
It compared shelters – considering costs, residents’ experiences and housing outcomes.
It found some very encouraging things about kauhale-like villages in Portland. People in these situations are more likely to find permanent housing. Earlier research had shown that people in the villages were quite satisfied with their housing but worried about food insecurity.
Most of all, though, the assessment asked all the right questions:
What were the programs trying to accomplish? Who benefitted and who was left out? What happens to the residents over time? How, if at all, does life improve? What’s the cost?
And finally, how is public money protected? Do emergency powers improve the government’s response?
The best thing about this kind of assessment is it takes place in an atmosphere protected from the Indignation Machine.
It also combines the auditor’s side of things with the “emergency powers” side, that complicated mix.
Take A Bated Breath
I wish I could say things look promising.
Last week in his interview with Civil Beat, Green had this to say about his homeless policy. Good advice, he said, isn’t going to come from the tiny house critics “because the auditor and those folks have not yet understood the catastrophic problem and how good it is to have thousands of people off the streets.”
Green plans to have a “really big conversation” with them “because now I can be a little more vocal.”
So patronizing. Such disdain. It sounds like mansplaining. Call it governorsplaining.
Still no recognition of the proper role of an auditor, more fuel to the Indignation Machine. And no expressed willingness to — as good as kauhale advocates think they are — look at what could make them even better.
And that’s so sad because Gov. Green is the key. Homeless policy is in his hands, and Kauhale has good potential.
His emergency powers give him a great opportunity to use his initiative if he does his part to turn off the spigot of the Indignation Machine.
Take a deep-deep breath, governor. Look in the mirror and repeat one of the famous management consultant Peter Drucker’s keys to effective leadership:
“Listen first, speak last.”
