Much of the public commentary surrounding the Ryan v. Watson lawsuit filed this year has focused on the 50% blood quantum requirement for Hawaiian Home Lands. For our community, this debate touches identity, family histories, and the urgent need to hold the state of Hawaiʻi and the Department of Hawaiian Home Lands accountable to their trust mandates.

Yet the lawsuit raises questions far beyond Hawaiian Home Lands. Brought by Eric Ryan, president of the Hawaii Republican Assembly, and represented by the Pacific Legal Foundation, a national public-interest law firm, it challenges the distinction between Indigenous political and racial classifications.

When the foundational trust instruments of the Native Hawaiian people are treated as mere equal-protection hurdles rather than solemn compacts, we are not just debating real estate — we risk the legal erasure of our standing as a people and the rights secured for future generations.



Ideas showcases stories, opinion and analysis about Hawaiʻi, from the state’s sharpest thinkers, to stretch our collective thinking about a problem or an issue. Email news@civilbeat.org to submit an idea or an essay.

The Trojan Horse Of “Equal Protection”

In his First Amended complaint, filed Oct. 23, 2026, plaintiff Eric Ryan continues his constitutional challenge to the Hawaiian Homes Commission Act. He invokes the Fourteenth Amendment’s equal protection clause against the State and the equal-protection component of the Fifth Amendment’s Due Process Clause against the federal government, arguing that the HHCA’s ancestry-based eligibility requirements constitute an impermissible racial classification.

The HHCA should not be reduced to a racial preference. It is a federally established remedial trust intended to rehabilitate an Indigenous population that suffered catastrophic demographic decline, widespread land dispossession, and the loss of its independent government.

Three legal considerations are central:

  • The Political Classification: In Morton v. Mancari (1974), the Supreme Court recognized a classification grounded in tribal political status and self-government as political, not racial. In Rice v. Cayetano (2000), the Court struck down ancestry restrictions in state-administered OHA elections under the Fifteenth Amendment but declined to decide whether Mancari applies to Native Hawaiians. The HHCA presents a distinct question involving a federal trust enactment incorporated into Hawaiʻi’s statehood compact.
  • The Statehood Compact: Section 4 of the 1959 Admission Act required Hawaiʻi to incorporate the HHCA into its Constitution and restricts changes to beneficiary qualifications without federal consent. This binding federal-state compact is central to understanding the HHCA, rather than treating it as an ordinary state housing preference.
  • Federal Trust Responsibilities: On Jan. 16, 2025, the Department of the Interior issued Solicitor’s Opinion M-37083 addressing federal trust responsibilities concerning Native Hawaiians and Hawaiian Home Lands. Suspended for review on February 28, 2025, it remains a record of legal analysis, not currently operative guidance.

Ryan nevertheless seeks to subject HHCA eligibility requirements to strict scrutiny as a racial classification, notwithstanding the trust’s distinct federal statutory foundation.

The Domino Effect

The constitutional reasoning advanced against the HHCA could have implications beyond Hawaiian Home Lands if courts or future litigants attempt to apply it to other Native Hawaiian institutions.

Consider Princess Bernice Pauahi Bishop, the last direct descendant of the Kamehameha royal line. Her will established a private charitable trust providing for Kamehameha Schools, directing trustees to give “the preference to Hawaiians of pure or part aboriginal blood” in educational support for orphans and others in need.

Pauahi’s bequest reflects her enduring commitment to her people’s future. Although the Bishop Estate rests on a legal foundation distinct from the HHCA, broader arguments concerning ancestry-based protections warrant vigilance. We must safeguard these institutions while recognizing the distinct legal foundations upon which each stands.

The Broader Constitutional Stakes For Water Rights

Ryan v. Watson does not directly challenge water rights, but its legal theories offer a cautionary lesson. Traditional and customary practices, including water uses, are protected under Article XII, Section 7, of Hawaiʻi’s Constitution, subject to state regulatory authority. Article XI, Sections 1 and 7, establish public-trust duties concerning natural resources and water.

The Waiāhole Ditch decisions affirm those duties, including protection of water for traditional uses. Rights involving kalo cultivation, gathering, and cultural practices have independent constitutional and public-trust foundations. We must remain alert to arguments that could undermine them.

A Call For Unity And Action

Prince Jonah Kūhiō Kalanianaʻole initially advocated a 1/32 eligibility threshold to include as many beneficiaries as possible. The 50% requirement emerged from political compromises with powerful sugar and ranching interests.

These interests operated within a plantation-dominated political economy with deep ties to missionary-descended families and business leaders, some of whom participated in the 1893 overthrow of the Hawaiian Kingdom. Kūhiō’s struggle to secure homelands unfolded within that legacy of land dispossession and concentrated political power.

DHHL sign
The Department of Hawaiian Home Lands is under legal threat. DHHL

We cannot allow external legal challenges to exploit internal debates over eligibility to dismantle the trust itself. Those seeking reform and those defending the trust share the same objective: preserving Kūhiō’s legacy of rehabilitating our people on ancestral land.

As litigation proceeds, the Native Hawaiian community must remain informed, engaged, and prepared to defend its rights. We must exercise our political agency to safeguard our inheritance for generations yet unborn. We must do more than defend what earlier generations secured; we must strengthen our political institutions, advance our constitutional development, and protect our vested rights and the international standing of the Hawaiian nation.

Prince Kūhiō did not fight to secure a permanent foundation on ancestral soil only to see that legacy threatened by legal arguments that reduce our political and trust rights to matters of race alone.

E kū paʻa i ka ʻāina — stand firm on the land. It is now up to us to protect that heritage. This is our ʻāina, our wai, and our future. We cannot afford to wait for someone else to defend them.

Community Voices aims to encourage broad discussion on topics of community interest. Find out more here, including our policy on use of AI. This is your space to talk about important issues or interesting people, or to respond to previous commentary or news stories. Column lengths should be no more than 800 words and we need a photo of the author and a bio. Send to news@civilbeat.org.

Elizabeth Hoʻoipo Pa Nakea is an attorney, community advocate, and retired special education teacher from James B. Castle High School. As co-founder of the Native Hawaiian Advisory Council and inaugural president of Hui Naʻauao, she has spent decades advocating for Lāhui political autonomy, protecting...